7 Common School Audit Findings and What Leaders Can Do

Intersecting staircases in a modern building feature deep teal structures, bright orange walls, glass railings, and natural light, symbolizing the interconnected systems and pathways that support meaningful school improvement. The Remfrey Educational Consulting logo appears in the bottom right corner.
Loading the Elevenlabs Text to Speech AudioNative Player...

Every school I visit is different. Different students, different cultures, different approaches to teaching and learning. But after years of conducting inclusive practices audits at international schools, I’ve noticed that many of the same challenges keep showing up.

And they’re often found in schools with committed educators, talented specialists, and leaders who truly believe in inclusion.

So what’s getting in the way?

More often than you might expect, it’s the systems surrounding those educators. A policy that sounds wonderful but means different things to different people. A Student Support Team doing excellent work without a clear way to coordinate with other departments. Professional development that inspires teachers in September but hasn’t changed much by June.

Recently, I looked back across several of my audit reports to study those patterns and the recommendations they had in common. Here are seven that stood out, along with the research backed changes I most often recommend to school leaders.

1. The Inclusion Statement Doesn’t Match Daily Practice

Most schools have a thoughtful statement about inclusion in their guiding documents. The challenge is what it means to the people putting it into practice. In a single week on campus, I might hear leaders describe inclusion as access to enrollment, teachers describe it as accommodations, and families describe it as something else entirely.

Without a shared understanding, sections of the school develop their own procedures, and staff isn’t always sure who decides on support or curriculum modifications. Students may still be getting good support. But when a board member, an accreditation team, or a family asks how those decisions get made, the school may struggle to show a consistent, transparent process.

What leaders can do: Bring together people from across the school to define what inclusion looks like in practice, including who is responsible for which decisions. Then check that your policies, professional learning, and everyday choices reflect that definition.

Ask yourself: Could we explain to a new family, in plain language, how our school decides what support a student receives?

2. Student Services Work as Separate Departments

International schools often have an impressive range of specialists, including learning support teachers, counselors, and English as an additional language (EAL) teachers. Each team may be excellent. The gaps appear when a student needs more than one of them.

Picture a student working through academic, language, and emotional regulation challenges at the same time. Three specialists set three sets of goals and share them with teachers through three different channels. Everyone cares, but no one is holding the full picture, and the family is left to connect the dots.

What leaders can do: Establish a shared multi-tiered system of support (MTSS) with emphasis on the support that gives teams a common language and clear referral pathways. Map how a concern moves from the first conversation through intervention, review, and exit. Decide who keeps the whole student in view. When departments feel disconnected, it’s tempting to restructure or hire another administrator to pull them together. More often, what’s missing is clarity about roles and processes, not another layer of leadership. 

I dug into what makes these systems work day-to-day with Larissa Napolitan, who hosts Schoolin’ Around, the podcast from MTSS software company Branching Minds. Our conversation covered how everyday routines become the foundation for larger systems of support, and why trust and calm are good signs that a system is working.

Ask yourself: When a student needs support from several teams, who is responsible for coordinating it?

3. Collaboration Depends on Goodwill

In nearly every school I visit, I meet educators who find time to consult colleagues and solve problems together. That dedication is wonderful. But when collaboration depends on individual initiative, it will vary considerably from team to team. One teacher has a strong partnership with a learning support specialist. Down the hall, another teacher rarely sees that same colleague. Co-teaching follows the same pattern. Two adults in a room aren’t automatically collaborating, especially if they’ve never had time to plan together.

What leaders can do: Treat collaboration as part of the school’s design. Protect time for teachers and specialists to plan and review student progress together, and make sure meetings end with instructional decisions, not just updates. Professional learning communities (PLCs) offer a useful structure when teams share responsibility for student learning.

Ask yourself: Where in our schedule is collaboration protected, what is the protocol for those meetings, and where does the data live that is discussed during that time?

4. Professional Development Doesn’t Change Practice

Schools invest real time and money in professional development, and teachers often speak highly of it. But picture a school that introduces Universal Design for Learning (UDL) with a series of workshops. Teachers leave with great resources, and some start applying the principles right away. Others aren’t sure how to turn them into everyday planning conversations, and without someone to observe, give feedback, or plan alongside them, they’re left to figure it out alone. 

It’s rarely about motivation. Teachers need chances to practice, get feedback, and learn alongside colleagues, and a single workshop can’t provide that.

What leaders can do: Tie professional learning to a few clearly defined priorities and stay with them for more than one year. Build in coaching, observation, and collaborative planning so teachers have support while they try new approaches. Then judge success by changes in classroom practice rather than attendance or satisfaction surveys. Will Coman digs into this in his post on purposefully designed professional development.

Ask yourself: Can we point to specific changes in teaching that came from our last major professional development investment?

5. Support Is Measured by Hours, Not Progress

When schools talk about student support, the conversation often centers on how much a student receives. How many minutes of learning support? How many sessions a week? Those numbers help with planning, but they don’t tell you whether the support is working.

I often see students who receive the same intervention all semester, with broad goals and inconsistent progress monitoring data. At the end of the term, the support continues because no one has a clear basis for changing it. For leaders, that’s both an equity question and a budget question.

What leaders can do: Set clear expectations for how goals are written, monitored, and reviewed. Use Student Support Team meetings to look at evidence and decide whether to continue, change, intensify, or gradually reduce support. And include independence and participation in your definition of progress.

Ask yourself: Can we show that our interventions are helping students make progress?

6. Staffing Follows Numbers, Not Needs

Staffing is one of the hardest calls leaders make. Budgets are finite, enrollment shifts, and student needs change from year to year. It’s understandable that schools reach for simple formulas.

But consider two specialists who each have 20 students on their caseload. On paper, their workloads match. In reality, one mostly monitors students with accommodations, while the other teaches intensively, coordinates with multiple classroom teachers, attends frequent meetings, and creates individualized materials. A formula based on student numbers can’t see that difference, and the result is often uneven support and stretched staff.

What leaders can do: Look at caseload complexity and how specialists spend their time, including assessment, documentation, consultation, and family communication. Clarify the roles of learning support teachers, EAL teachers, and assistants. Before adding staff, ask whether a different service delivery model or stronger classroom practice would reach more students.

Ask yourself: Do we know how our student support service personnel spend their week, and does that match where students need them most?

7. Initiatives Start Strong and Fade

A new referral process or co-teaching model launches with real energy. Then the year gets busy. Priorities shift, and in international schools, the people who championed the change often move on. New staff never learn the original approach, and a few years later, a review turns up many of the same concerns.

The practice may have taken hold at first. What was missing was clear ownership, a plan for when key people leave, and regular check-ins in the years that followed.

What leaders can do: Before launching something new, look at what happened to past efforts, including recommendations from earlier reviews. Choose a manageable number of priorities and commit to them for more than one year. Assign an owner to each, and build the work into induction so new staff learn it too. Share decisions and the reasoning behind them, so people can see what happened to their feedback.

Ask yourself: Which of our recent improvement efforts are still standing, and which have quietly faded?

Where Should Your School Begin?

If you recognized your school in more than one of these patterns, you’re in good company. Even schools with strong inclusive practices have room to improve how their systems work together. As Dr Daniel Sobel says, “Inclusion isn’t the goal, it is the method.”

Some changes can happen quickly. Clarifying a referral process or setting a regular meeting between support teams can make a difference within weeks. Others, like building a shared understanding of inclusion or rethinking how staff is deployed, take sustained leadership over several years.

Heifetz and colleagues (2009) describe these as technical and adaptive challenges. Technical challenges can be addressed using existing knowledge and expertise, while adaptive challenges require new learning, different ways of thinking, and collective problem solving. In our audit reports, the REC team uses this distinction to organize recommendations into Quick Wins and Long Term Strategies. Both matter. Early wins build confidence and momentum, while the longer work brings the community together to create the conditions for lasting progress.

It also helps to look for connections. A challenge that seems to belong to student services may have its roots in scheduling, communication, or professional learning. Seeing those links across the whole school is one of the most valuable things an inclusive practices audit offers.

Try reading through the “Ask Yourself” questions with your leadership team. Notice which ones you can answer confidently and which ones spark debate. That’s usually a good place to start.

Ready to experience a custom audit for your school? Contact us to find out how an inclusive practices audit can help your team set priorities.

Reference

Heifetz, R. A., Grashow, A., & Linsky, M. (2009). The practice of adaptive leadership: Tools and tactics for changing your organization and the world. Harvard Business Press.

‍

Inclusion Insights for Intentional Educators

Get curated monthly resources delivered: must-read articles, practical tools, and proven strategies that support every learner.
*Timely insights. Inclusive by design. Always student-centered.